Should you build your own NAS, or buy one?


Resource connection

Let us get a person factor out of the way. If you might be a individual who normally builds your personal PCs or servers, this short article isn’t for you. If you might be the kind who would normally build your personal NAS, go forward. I am not telling you not to.

In its place, this short article is for the individual who’s definitely trying to comprehend the trade-offs, to come to a decision what the finest study course of motion is dependent on charge, energy, and other things. If you might be on the fence or just discovering about how to manage your personal storage array, read on.

I’ll be genuine. At this point, I have lost monitor of how much storage I have below in my dwelling place of work. I’ll explain to you it truly is someplace north of 150 terabytes, in all probability closer to 200 by now. Since of the varieties of work tasks I have experienced to do above the years, I have normally required a whole lot of storage.

Right up until about 5 years or so in the past, I normally designed my personal. That approach culminated in the media tank builds I did in the mid-2000s. These two devices each experienced 10 drive bays, together with a person boot drive. One tank was for stay data, and the other retained backups of the principal server.

At that time, it was difficult to get a desktop dimensions (or desktop finances) NAS that would hold as lots of drives as I required to operate. One equipment experienced 10 1TB drives, though the next experienced 10 2TB drives.

Developing them was fun, but difficult and a bit troublesome. The massive energy was sourcing all the elements. At the time, it was comparatively uncomplicated to hang up to 6 drives off of a person motherboard, but adding an additional 5 needed some include-on boards. Generating it uncomplicated to eliminate and swap the drives needed two 5-bay drive trays. I identified some good conditions that experienced house for all the bays, but I experienced to do some slicing, drilling, and bashing to make it all healthy.

When every little thing worked, I experienced to established up the file sharing system (which was initially dependent on XP, then Home windows 8, and then, ultimately, Linux). All in all, it was fun. But far more importantly, I experienced the storage array I required in the finances I could devote.

But then came the age of appliance NAS gadgets, like the Drobo and Synology devices. When it came time to include far more storage, I decided to move to my very first Drobo array. Setup was a cinch. Above time, I wound up getting four Drobos, each direct-connected and networked. I identified that the relieve of set up and the relieve of upkeep was very compelling, particularly given that I was so occupied.

Ultimately, the hand-created NAS packing containers, the massive tanks, received relegated to offline backup storage. By the time we moved to Oregon in the tumble, those tanks experienced been offline for a few years and I understood it was time to just take them permanently out of service.

Above the study course of 2017, I experienced a probability to seem at 7 desktop NAS gadgets, including the Drobos and the finest-in-show Synology devices, and it turned abundantly obvious that the era of very capable and charge-productive appliance NAS gadgets is below.

At this point, I are unable to suggest making your personal NAS unless of course you have a exclusive need which is just not achieved by an appliance NAS. On the other hand, as my overview sequence confirmed, you can find an appliance NAS with just about any function you could possibly want, including direct output to a Tv, if you took place to want such a factor.

I a short while ago tried using to value equivalent components to what I was managing in my dwelling-designed NAS packing containers and came up with about $750. Which is not all that much of a price savings above the appliance gadgets, particularly if you issue in not only your time, but the vitality charges of a even larger tower equipment. The Synology DS1817+ charges only $850, with every little thing established up, configured, and completely ready to operate.

Currently, definitely, the only motive I’d definitely suggest you go out and build your personal NAS is for the expertise and fun of putting a person collectively. Which is nonetheless a very valid motive, particularly if you want to gain familiarity with the technologies and NAS server software package.

But if you just want to get and set up trustworthy storage, I’d suggest that you obtain it. It will conserve you a ton of time, is not going to charge you much far more, and the gadgets now on the current market, specifically the Synology gadgets managing Disk Station Supervisor, are remarkable. I have no options to ever build an additional NAS.

As for the two massive media tank tower devices, they have been donated to a very good lead to.

You can stick to my day-to-day venture updates on social media. Be guaranteed to stick to me on Twitter at @DavidGewirtz, on Facebook at, on Instagram at


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here